Sheffield United have played York City 8 times in competitive football, winning 6, drawing 2 and losing 0, first meeting on 10 Jan 1931 and most recently on 10 Sep 2002. Every meeting is listed below.
| Date | Season | Competition | Venue | Opponent | Score | Scorers | Att |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Jan 1931 | 1930–31 | FA Cup | H | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 14 Jan 1931 | 1930–31 | FA Cup | A | York City | 2–0 | ||
| 5 Oct 1971 | 1971–72 | League Cup | H | York City | 3–2 | ||
| 1 Sep 1981 | 1981–82 | League Cup | H | York City | 1–0 | ||
| 15 Sep 1981 | 1981–82 | League Cup | A | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 3 Oct 1981 | 1981–82 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 4–3 | ||
| 13 Feb 1982 | 1981–82 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 4–0 | ||
| 10 Sep 2002 | 2002–03 | League Cup | H | York City | 1–0 | Jon-Paul McGovern | 4,675 |
All Sheffield United head-to-head records · Sheffield United season by season