Sheffield United have played Grimsby Town 65 times in competitive football, winning 38, drawing 12 and losing 15, first meeting on 14 Nov 1891 and most recently on 9 Nov 2016. Every meeting is listed below.
| Date | Season | Competition | Venue | Opponent | Score | Scorers | Att |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 Nov 1891 | 1891–92 | FA Cup | A | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | Harry Hammond, Samuel Dobson | 4,500 |
| 27 Sep 1892 | 1892–93 | Second Division | H | Grimsby Town | 2–0 | Ernest Needham | 4,500 |
| 31 Mar 1893 | 1892–93 | Second Division | A | Grimsby Town | 1–0 | Bob Hill | 6,000 |
| 28 Dec 1901 | 1901–02 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 1–0 | ||
| 11 Feb 1902 | 1901–02 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 2–2 | ||
| 13 Dec 1902 | 1902–03 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | ||
| 11 Apr 1903 | 1902–03 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 3–0 | ||
| 25 Sep 1915 | 1915–16 | Wartime League | H | Grimsby Town | 6–1 | Joseph Kitchen, Billy Gillespie, George Utley, Ben Shearman | 7,000 |
| 25 Dec 1915 | 1915–16 | Wartime League | A | Grimsby Town | 1–2 | Kay | 5,000 |
| 25 Mar 1916 | 1915–16 | Wartime League | A | Grimsby Town | 1–0 | Billy Gillespie | 2,000 |
| 29 Apr 1916 | 1915–16 | Wartime League | H | Grimsby Town | 0–0 | 6,000 | |
| 31 Aug 1929 | 1929–30 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 2–3 | ||
| 28 Dec 1929 | 1929–30 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 1–4 | ||
| 13 Dec 1930 | 1930–31 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 1–2 | ||
| 18 Apr 1931 | 1930–31 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | ||
| 24 Oct 1931 | 1931–32 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 2–0 | ||
| 5 Mar 1932 | 1931–32 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | ||
| 11 Feb 1939 | 1938–39 | FA Cup | H | Grimsby Town | 0–0 | ||
| 14 Feb 1939 | 1938–39 | FA Cup | A | Grimsby Town | 0–1 | ||
| 14 Sep 1946 | 1946–47 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 1–1 | ||
| 18 Jan 1947 | 1946–47 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 1–2 | ||
| 6 Sep 1947 | 1947–48 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 3–0 | ||
| 17 Jan 1948 | 1947–48 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 4–0 | ||
| 24 Sep 1949 | 1949–50 | Second Division | A | Grimsby Town | 0–4 | ||
| 4 Feb 1950 | 1949–50 | Second Division | H | Grimsby Town | 3–1 | ||
| 14 Oct 1950 | 1950–51 | Second Division | A | Grimsby Town | 2–2 | ||
| 3 Mar 1951 | 1950–51 | Second Division | H | Grimsby Town | 4–2 | ||
| 17 Nov 1956 | 1956–57 | Second Division | A | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | ||
| 30 Mar 1957 | 1956–57 | Second Division | H | Grimsby Town | 2–0 | ||
| 2 Nov 1957 | 1957–58 | Second Division | H | Grimsby Town | 3–1 | ||
| 4 Jan 1958 | 1957–58 | FA Cup | H | Grimsby Town | 5–1 | ||
| 15 Mar 1958 | 1957–58 | Second Division | A | Grimsby Town | 3–1 | ||
| 25 Dec 1958 | 1958–59 | Second Division | A | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | ||
| 27 Dec 1958 | 1958–59 | Second Division | H | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | ||
| 15 Dec 1979 | 1979–80 | FA Cup | A | Grimsby Town | 0–2 | ||
| 29 Dec 1979 | 1979–80 | Third Division | H | Grimsby Town | 1–1 | ||
| 3 May 1980 | 1979–80 | Third Division | A | Grimsby Town | 0–4 | ||
| 12 Oct 1982 | 1982–83 | League Cup | A | Grimsby Town | 3–3 | ||
| 26 Oct 1982 | 1982–83 | League Cup | H | Grimsby Town | 5–1 | ||
| 29 Sep 1984 | 1984–85 | Second Division | H | Grimsby Town | 2–3 | ||
| 2 Feb 1985 | 1984–85 | Second Division | A | Grimsby Town | 2–0 | ||
| 12 Oct 1985 | 1985–86 | Second Division | A | Grimsby Town | 1–0 | ||
| 15 Mar 1986 | 1985–86 | Second Division | H | Grimsby Town | 1–1 | ||
| 20 Sep 1986 | 1986–87 | Second Division | H | Grimsby Town | 1–2 | ||
| 28 Feb 1987 | 1986–87 | Second Division | A | Grimsby Town | 0–1 | ||
| 8 Oct 1994 | 1994–95 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 0–0 | ||
| 6 May 1995 | 1994–95 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 3–1 | ||
| 21 Nov 1995 | 1995–96 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 1–2 | ||
| 20 Apr 1996 | 1995–96 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 2–0 | ||
| 3 Nov 1996 | 1996–97 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 4–2 | Don Hutchison 27, Dane Whitehouse 44, Katchouro 80, Dane Whitehouse 82 | 5,935 |
| 22 Feb 1997 | 1996–97 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 3–1 | Jan Åge Fjørtoft 45, Jan Åge Fjørtoft 62, Jan Åge Fjørtoft 68 | 17,502 |
| 8 Sep 1998 | 1998–99 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 3–2 | Nicky Marker, Nicky Marker, John McDermott | 12,293 |
| 15 Sep 1998 | 1998–99 | League Cup | H | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | I Hamilton, Bobby Ford | 4,689 |
| 22 Sep 1998 | 1998–99 | League Cup | A | Grimsby Town | 0–2 | 4,287 | |
| 20 Apr 1999 | 1998–99 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | Andy Campbell, Andy Campbell | 5,109 |
| 3 Jan 2000 | 1999–00 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 2–2 | Marcus Bent, Paul Hall | 7,618 |
| 8 Apr 2000 | 1999–00 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 0–0 | 11,612 | |
| 18 Nov 2000 | 2000–01 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 3–2 | Georges Santos, Marcus Bent, Marcus Bent | 12,861 |
| 21 Apr 2001 | 2000–01 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 1–0 | Peter Ndlovu | 6,983 |
| 11 Sep 2001 | 2001–02 | League Cup | A | Grimsby Town | 2–2 | 5,236 | |
| 13 Oct 2001 | 2001–02 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 3–1 | Patrick Suffo, Patrick Suffo, Michael Brown | 15,442 |
| 16 Feb 2002 | 2001–02 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 0–1 | 7,141 | |
| 17 Sep 2002 | 2002–03 | First Division | H | Grimsby Town | 2–1 | Wayne Allison 82, Michael Tonge 89 | 14,208 |
| 4 Mar 2003 | 2002–03 | First Division | A | Grimsby Town | 4–1 | ||
| 9 Nov 2016 | 2016–17 | EFL Trophy | A | Grimsby Town | 4–2 | Regan Slater 53, Andrew Boyce 74, Jack O'Connell 78, Leon Clarke 87 | 597 |
See also: the Grimsby Town archive and Grimsby Town v Sheffield United.
All Sheffield United head-to-head records · Sheffield United season by season