Everton have played Exeter City 3 times in competitive football, winning 2, drawing 1 and losing 0, first meeting on 5 Jan 1986 and most recently on 21 Dec 1999. Every meeting is listed below.
| Date | Season | Competition | Venue | Opponent | Score | Scorers | Att |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 Jan 1986 | 1985–86 | FA Cup | H | Exeter City | 1–0 | Gary Stevens 80 | 22,726 |
| 11 Dec 1999 | 1999–00 | FA Cup | A | Exeter City | 0–0 | 6,045 | |
| 21 Dec 1999 | 1999–00 | FA Cup | H | Exeter City | 1–0 | Nick Barmby | 15,345 |
See also: the Exeter City archive and Exeter City v Everton.