Everton have played Darwen 4 times in competitive football, winning 2, drawing 1 and losing 1, first meeting on 7 Sep 1891 and most recently on 1 Jan 1894. Every meeting is listed below.
| Date | Season | Competition | Venue | Opponent | Score | Scorers | Att |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 Sep 1891 | 1891–92 | First Division | H | Darwen | 5–3 | ||
| 14 Nov 1891 | 1891–92 | First Division | A | Darwen | 1–3 | ||
| 21 Oct 1893 | 1893–94 | First Division | H | Darwen | 8–1 | Ales Latta, Ales Latta, Alan Maxwell, Alan Maxwell, Jack Southworth, Jack Southworth, Edgar Chadwick, Jack Bell | 9,000 |
| 1 Jan 1894 | 1893–94 | First Division | A | Darwen | 3–3 | Jack Southworth, Edgar Chadwick, John Leach | 10,000 |