Everton have played Barnsley 16 times in competitive football, winning 10, drawing 4 and losing 2, first meeting on 16 Jan 1909 and most recently on 26 Aug 2015. Every meeting is listed below.
| Date | Season | Competition | Venue | Opponent | Score | Scorers | Att |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Jan 1909 | 1908–09 | FA Cup | H | Barnsley | 3–1 | ||
| 26 Mar 1910 | 1909–10 | FA Cup | N | Barnsley | 0–0 | 36,000 | |
| 31 Mar 1910 | 1909–10 | FA Cup | N | Barnsley | 0–3 | 55,000 | |
| 9 Jan 1915 | 1914–15 | FA Cup | H | Barnsley | 3–0 | ||
| 11 Oct 1930 | 1930–31 | Second Division | A | Barnsley | 1–1 | ||
| 18 Feb 1931 | 1930–31 | Second Division | H | Barnsley | 5–2 | ||
| 8 Dec 1951 | 1951–52 | Second Division | A | Barnsley | 0–1 | ||
| 26 Apr 1952 | 1951–52 | Second Division | H | Barnsley | 1–1 | ||
| 10 Sep 1952 | 1952–53 | Second Division | A | Barnsley | 3–2 | 10,835 | |
| 1 Jan 1953 | 1952–53 | Second Division | H | Barnsley | 2–1 | 25,485 | |
| 15 Jan 1963 | 1962–63 | FA Cup | A | Barnsley | 3–0 | Brian Harris 72, Dennis Stevens 76, Roy Vernon 85 | 30,011 |
| 18 Feb 1989 | 1988–89 | FA Cup | A | Barnsley | 1–0 | Graeme Sharp | 32,551 |
| 13 Mar 1991 | 1990–91 | Full Members Cup | A | Barnsley | 1–0 | Tony Cottee | 10,287 |
| 20 Sep 1997 | 1997–98 | Premier League | H | Barnsley | 4–2 | Gary Speed, Gary Speed, Danny Cadamarteri, John Oster | 32,659 |
| 7 Feb 1998 | 1997–98 | Premier League | A | Barnsley | 2–2 | Duncan Ferguson, Tony Grant | 18,672 |
| 26 Aug 2015 | 2015–16 | League Cup | A | Barnsley | 5–3 | Kevin Mirallas 51, Steven Naismith 59, Romelu Lukaku 78, Marc Roberts 96, Romelu Lukaku 115 | 12,290 |
See also: the Barnsley archive and Barnsley v Everton.