Plymouth Argyle have played Chesterfield 58 times in competitive football, winning 23, drawing 17 and losing 18, first meeting on 31 Aug 1931 and most recently on 18 Mar 2014. Every meeting is listed below.
| Date | Season | Competition | Venue | Opponent | Score | Scorers | Att |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 31 Aug 1931 | 1931–32 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–1 | ||
| 7 May 1932 | 1931–32 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 4–0 | ||
| 29 Oct 1932 | 1932–33 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–1 | ||
| 11 Mar 1933 | 1932–33 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–0 | ||
| 3 Oct 1936 | 1936–37 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–0 | ||
| 6 Feb 1937 | 1936–37 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–1 | ||
| 11 Sep 1937 | 1937–38 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 0–2 | ||
| 26 Jan 1938 | 1937–38 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–1 | ||
| 5 Nov 1938 | 1938–39 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–3 | ||
| 11 Mar 1939 | 1938–39 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 0–0 | ||
| 11 Sep 1946 | 1946–47 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–0 | RA Thomas 49 | |
| 1 Jan 1947 | 1946–47 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–4 | DWJ Thomas 19 | |
| 1 Nov 1947 | 1947–48 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–1 | ||
| 20 Mar 1948 | 1947–48 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–2 | G Astall 25 | |
| 23 Oct 1948 | 1948–49 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 2–2 | M Tadman 45, M Tadman 53 | |
| 19 Mar 1949 | 1948–49 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 0–0 | ||
| 27 Aug 1949 | 1949–50 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 0–2 | ||
| 24 Dec 1949 | 1949–50 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 2–1 | MR Tadman 10, F Squires 80 | |
| 1 Nov 1958 | 1958–59 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–1 | TG Baker 34, W Cater 88 | |
| 21 Mar 1959 | 1958–59 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 2–0 | R Jenkins 8, W Carter 32 | |
| 14 Nov 1970 | 1970–71 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 0–2 | ||
| 13 Mar 1971 | 1970–71 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–1 | D Hutchins 40 | |
| 30 Oct 1971 | 1971–72 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–2 | DBP Rickard 77 | |
| 19 Feb 1972 | 1971–72 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–0 | LA Latcham 75 | |
| 26 Aug 1972 | 1972–73 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–2 | A Welsh 6, R Brown 80 | |
| 20 Feb 1973 | 1972–73 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 2–2 | N Hague 17, CJ Sullivan 47 | |
| 25 Aug 1973 | 1973–74 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–1 | Machin 28 | |
| 19 Jan 1974 | 1973–74 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 0–1 | ||
| 30 Nov 1974 | 1974–75 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–1 | WH Rafferty 23, P Mariner 83 | |
| 18 Jan 1975 | 1974–75 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 3–0 | JF Delve 28, P Mariner 80, BE Vassallo 84 | |
| 12 Nov 1977 | 1977–78 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 2–0 | TW Austin 75, BF Johnson 84 | |
| 8 Apr 1978 | 1977–78 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–4 | Binney 7 | |
| 19 Aug 1978 | 1978–79 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 3–1 | KW Fear 48, FE Binney 56, G Megson 70 | |
| 16 Dec 1978 | 1978–79 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–1 | G Megson 78 | |
| 25 Aug 1979 | 1979–80 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–3 | MT Graves 65 | |
| 29 Dec 1979 | 1979–80 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–0 | ||
| 13 Sep 1980 | 1980–81 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–2 | MT Graves 18, DM Kemp 75 | |
| 7 Feb 1981 | 1980–81 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–0 | BF Johnson 64 | |
| 26 Sep 1981 | 1981–82 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 0–2 | ||
| 20 Feb 1982 | 1981–82 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–2 | J Sims 36, JW Cook 60 | |
| 23 Oct 1982 | 1982–83 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–1 | K Hodges 11, GJM Nisbet 16 | |
| 5 Mar 1983 | 1982–83 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 2–0 | DO Phillips 70, A Rogers 83 | |
| 2 Nov 1985 | 1985–86 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 0–0 | ||
| 18 Mar 1986 | 1985–86 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–1 | K Summerfield 24, C Goodyear 44 | |
| 19 Nov 1996 | 1996–97 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 0–3 | 4,237 | |
| 22 Feb 1997 | 1996–97 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–1 | Mickey Evans, Mark Saunders | 5,833 |
| 30 Aug 1997 | 1997–98 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 1–1 | EJ Jean 31 | |
| 17 Jan 1998 | 1997–98 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–2 | DM Corazzin 33 | |
| 7 Oct 2000 | 2000–01 | Third Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–2 | Paul McGregor 47 | 4,285 |
| 10 Mar 2001 | 2000–01 | Third Division | H | Chesterfield | 3–0 | David Friio 20, Martin Phillips 61, Sean McCarthy 80 | 5,399 |
| 21 Sep 2002 | 2002–03 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 0–1 | 8,547 | |
| 8 Mar 2003 | 2002–03 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 2–3 | Marino Keith 15, Marino Keith 74 | 3,668 |
| 25 Aug 2003 | 2003–04 | Second Division | A | Chesterfield | 1–1 | David Friio 66 | 4,089 |
| 3 Jan 2004 | 2003–04 | Second Division | H | Chesterfield | 7–0 | Lee Hodges 4, Tony Capaldi 11, Nathan Lowndes 12, David Friio 15, Nathan Lowndes 18, David Friio 36, David Friio 88 | 13,109 |
| 24 Nov 2012 | 2012–13 | League Two | H | Chesterfield | 0–1 | 5,711 | |
| 16 Apr 2013 | 2012–13 | League Two | A | Chesterfield | 2–1 | Joe Bryan 21, Curtis Nelson 26 | 4,988 |
| 14 Dec 2013 | 2013–14 | League Two | A | Chesterfield | 0–2 | 4,486 | |
| 18 Mar 2014 | 2013–14 | League Two | H | Chesterfield | 2–1 | Reuben Reid 28, Reuben Reid 58 | 6,012 |
See also: the Chesterfield archive and Chesterfield v Plymouth Argyle.
All Plymouth Argyle head-to-head records · Plymouth Argyle season by season